Sue de Coq (Free Cell)
Loading demo...
Sue de Coq uses the intersection of a box and a row or column (the non-box house) to contribute one cell to an ALS in each house, forming two locked sets and enabling eliminations. This page covers the Free Cell form, where two of the three unfilled intersection cells form the actual intersection, or joint cells, and the remaining cell is the free cell.
How to spot it
- Check each intersection with exactly three unfilled cells, together with its box and non-box house (row or column).
- Try each cell in turn as the free cell, with the other two forming the actual intersection.
- Find one ALS in each house, outside the actual intersection. Call them the box ALS and the non-box ALS. The free cell may belong to either ALS or neither.
- The actual intersection must contain at least four distinct candidates, satisfying these conditions:
- All candidates come from the box ALS and the non-box ALS, with no extra candidate.
- At least two come from the box ALS.
- At least two come from the non-box ALS.
- The two candidate groups within the actual intersection are disjoint. (The ALSs themselves may contain the same candidates, but those candidates must be absent from the actual intersection.)
- Eliminations:
- Eliminate the box ALS's candidates from box cells outside both the box ALS and the actual intersection, including the free cell if it lies outside the box ALS.
- Eliminate the non-box ALS's candidates from cells in the non-box house outside both that ALS and the actual intersection, including the free cell if it lies outside the non-box ALS.
How it works
Once the above conditions are met, we can deduce the following: one cell in the actual intersection must take a digit from the box ALS, and the other from the non-box ALS.
The reasoning is the same as for Basic: if both joint cells took digits from the same ALS, it would be left with too few distinct digits to fill its cells, violating Sudoku rules. Only the two joint cells are considered in this reasoning; the free cell is not counted as a joint cell.
This gives the following eliminations:
- The box ALS and its corresponding joint cell form a locked set. Its candidates can be eliminated from box cells outside both the box ALS and the actual intersection.
- The non-box ALS and the other joint cell form a locked set. Its candidates can be eliminated from cells in the non-box house outside both that ALS and the actual intersection.
The free cell lies outside the joint cells, so it may be an elimination target. If it belongs to neither ALS, both houses' eliminations can affect it. If it belongs to one ALS, only the opposite ALS's eliminations can affect it. Removing a candidate present in both ALSs from a free cell that belongs to one ALS is called cannibalism.
Examples
(Free cell in the box ALS) The board above contains a Free Cell Sue de Coq structure in box 7 and column 2. The actual intersection is {R7C2, R9C2}; R8C2 is the free cell but belongs to the box ALS.
(Free cell in the non-box ALS) The board above contains a Free Cell Sue de Coq structure in box 2 and column 5. The actual intersection is {R2C5, R3C5}; R1C5 is the free cell but belongs to the column ALS.
(Free cell in neither ALS) The board above contains a Free Cell Sue de Coq structure in box 7 and column 2. The actual intersection is {R7C2, R8C2}; R9C2 is the free cell and belongs to neither ALS.
(Cannibalism) The board above contains a Free Cell Sue de Coq structure in box 3 and row 1. The actual intersection is {R1C7, R1C9}. The free cell R1C8 belongs to the box ALS, but it lies outside the actual intersection, so candidate 9, which is present in the row ALS, can be eliminated from it.